What’s the Difference Between a Tin Roof and Metal Roof?

When people talk about metal roofing, the term “tin roof” often comes up. But is a tin roof the same as a modern metal roofing system like the ones offered by Watson Metals? Not quite. While tin was once used in roofing, today’s metal roofs are engineered with stronger, more durable materials designed to last for decades.

If you’re considering a metal roof for your home, barn, or business, it’s essential to understand the differences between tin roofs and modern steel roofing panels so you can make the best investment. Let’s break it down.

What is a Tin Roof?

Historically, tin roofs were made from tin-plated iron or steel sheets. These sheets were lightweight and relatively resistant to rust, making them a popular roofing choice in the 19th and early 20th centuries. However, true tin roofs are extremely rare today because modern materials provide far superior strength and protection.

Many people still use the term “tin roof” when referring to metal roofing, but what they’re actually describing is modern metal roofing panels – like the ones Watson Metals supplies.

What is a Metal Roof Like the Ones from Watson Metals?

Watson Metals provides high-quality metal roofing panels, engineered for long-term durability, superior weather resistance, and low maintenance. Unlike outdated tin roofs, modern metal panels are coated for corrosion resistance and designed to withstand extreme conditions.

Most metal roofs today are made from one of two materials:


Galvanized Steel 

Coated with a protective layer of zinc to prevent rust and corrosion.

Galvalume® Steel 

A combination of aluminum and zinc, providing even greater corrosion resistance and longevity.

Watson Metals offers advanced metal roofing options, ensuring that your roof lasts for decades with minimal upkeep.

Tin Roof vs. Modern Metal Roof: Key Differences

FeatureTin RoofMetal Roof (Watson Metals)
MaterialTin-plated iron or steelHigh-grade steel 
DurabilityProne to denting, less impact-resistantStrong, impact-resistant, designed to last 40-70 years
Corrosion ResistanceSusceptible to rust over timeAdvanced coatings for superior rust resistance
Weather ResistanceLimited wind and hail resistanceEngineered to withstand high winds, heavy rain, and hail
Energy EfficiencyBasic, absorbs heatReflective coatings reduce heat absorption, lowering cooling costs
MaintenanceRequires frequent upkeep and repaintingLow maintenance, long-lasting color retention
Lifespan20-30 years with upkeep40-70 years with minimal maintenance

Why a Metal Roof is the Better Choice

If you’re considering a new metal roof, here’s why you should choose a modern steel roof from Watson Metals over an outdated tin roof:

Built to Last

Modern steel roofing panels are stronger and more durable than tin. With a lifespan of 40-70 years, they outperform tin roofs, which typically last only 20-30 years with heavy maintenance.

Better Protection Against the Elements

Tennessee and Kentucky experience strong winds, hail, and heavy rain—conditions that tin roofs don’t handle well. Watson Metals’ steel roofing panels are engineered to resist extreme weather, reducing the risk of damage and leaks.

Energy Efficient & Cost-Saving

Our metal roofing panels feature reflective coatings that reduce heat absorption, helping to lower cooling costs in the summer. Traditional tin roofs lack these coatings and absorb more heat, making your home or building less energy-efficient.

Low Maintenance, High Performance

Unlike tin, which requires frequent repainting and rust prevention, modern steel roofing panels have protective coatings that eliminate the need for constant maintenance.

Aesthetic Options to Match Any Building

Watson Metals offers a wide range of colors and finishes that maintain their appearance for decades. Tin roofs, by contrast, fade and require frequent repainting to maintain curb appeal.

Upgrade to a Durable, Modern Metal Roof with Watson Metals

If you’re looking for a long-lasting, low-maintenance, and high-performance metal roof, Watson Metals has the materials you need. Our metal roofing panels are far superior to outdated tin roofing, offering better durability, weather resistance, and energy efficiency.

Contact Watson Metals today to get a quote or learn more about why our modern steel roofing panels are the best choice for your next project. Let’s build something that lasts!

Posted in

Aaron Sackett

Scroll to Top